32 Main St, Hamburg, NY 14075

716-648-5017
Order Online
Order Appetit

Food Menu

by | Feb 5, 2023

    • Appetizers

    • Chips and Salsa

      $7.34

      House Made Tortilla Chips/House Made Salsa

    • Pull-Apart Cheese Bread

      $10.49
      $1.67 - Add Side of Red Sauce

      House Made Loaf / Mozzarella Cheese / Garlic Butter / Parmesan Cheese

    • Garlic Bread w/Cheese

      $7.34 - Sm.
      $12.06 - Lg.

      Home-made bread topped with garlic butter & cheese baked in the brick oven, served with marinara sauce

    • Seasoned Wedges

      $7.34

      Wedges / Cajun Seasoning

    • Sweet Potato Wedges

      $8.39

      Sweet Potato Wedges / Cajun Seasoning / Served with Sriracha Ranch

    • French Fries

      $8.39

      Fries / Salt & Pepper

    • Stuffed Banana Peppers

      $13.64

      Hot Banana Peppers / Sausage / Provolone Cheese / Marinara/Parmesan / Garlic Toast

    • Stuffed Mushrooms

      $13.64

      Mushroom Caps / Sausage / Mozzarella Cheese / Marinara / Parmesan / Garlic Toast

    • Buffalo Mozzarella

      $12.59

      Fresh mozzarella / Panko / Served with Sriracha Ranch, Honey Mustard, BBQ

    • Butera’s Trio

      $12.59

      Three House-Made Pizza Logs; Cheese & Pepperoni / Beef on Weck / Bacon Cheeseburger / Served with Creamy Horseradish, Marinara, Thousand Island

    • Crab Cakes

      $18.89

      Crab Cakes / Arugula / Served with Cajun Remoulade

    • Pizza Flight

      $18.89

      Your choice of 3 miniature pizzas off the regular pizza menu

    • Beef on Weck Poutine

      $14.69

      Seasoned Wedges / Gravy / Cheese Curds / Slow Roasted Beef / Creamy Horseradish Sauce / Salt & Caraway Seeds

    • Buffalo Shrimp

      $13.64

      6 Shrimp / Choice of Sauce / Choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch

    • Wings & Fingers

      Sauce Options: Mild/Medium/Hot Specialty Sauce Options: (+$2): Honey Mustard/Cajun (wet or dry)/Honey Garlic/Garlic Parmesan/BBQ

    • Boneless Wings

      $15.74 (10)
      $20.99 (20)

    • Chicken Wings

      $15.74 (10)
      $28.34 (20)

    • Chicken Fingers

      $15.74

      Four Chicken Fingers / House-Made Tortilla Chips or Seasoned Wedges or Choice of Cup of Soup. Substitute Side Options (+$2.99) Sweet Potato Wedges, French fries, Mac Salad, Coleslaw, or House Salad

    • BCBP Wings

      $17.84 (10)
      $30.44 (20)

      Hot Sauce / BBQ / Arugula / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Balsamic Glaze

    • Soups & Salads

      Dressing Options: Italian/Creamy Italian/Ranch/Sriracha Ranch/Bleu Cheese/Caesar/Balsamic Vinaigrette/Tzatziki/Greek/Thousand Island/Honey Mustard

    • Soup of the Day

      $5.24 (Cup)
      $6.81 (Bowl)

    • Beer Cheddar

      $5.24 (Cup)
      $6.81 (Bowl)

    • French Onion

      $5.24 (Cup)
      $6.81 (Bowl)

    • House Salad

      $11.54

      Spring Mix / Red Onion / Black Olives / Tomatoes / Sweet Peppers / Mozzarella Cheese / Croutons / Served with Dressing of Choice

    • House Caesar

      $12.59

      Romaine Lettuce / Parmesan / Croutons / Caesar Dressing

    • Chicken Caesar Salad

      $16.01

      Romaine Lettuce / Parmesan / Croutons / Caesar Dressing / Chicken

    • Antipasto

      $18.36

      Spring Mix / Red Onion / Black Olives / Banana Peppers / Tomatoes / Mozzarella Cheese / Salami / Capicola / Prosciutto / Pepperoni / Served with Dressing of Choice

    • Greek Chicken Salad

      $16.01

      Spring Mix / Red Onion / Black Olives / Banana Peppers / Tomatoes / Feta Cheese / Pita / Served with Greek and Tzatziki Dressings

    • Blackened Chicken Salad

      $16.01

      Spring Mix / Bacon Bits / Crumbly Bleu Cheese / Cajun Chicken / Served with Dressing of Choice

    • Wraps

      Served with House-Made Tortilla Chips, or Choice of Cup of Soup. Substitute Side Options (+$2.99) Regular Potato Wedges, Sweet Potato Wedges, French Fries, Mac Salad, Coleslaw, or House Salad Substitute a Gluten Free Roll for +$2.49

    • Grilled Chicken Wrap

      $14.69

      Spring Mix / Grilled Chicken / Tomato / Provolone Cheese / Choice of Honey Mustard or Balsamic Vinaigrette / Garden Spinach Wrap

    • Chicken Caesar Bacon Wrap

      $15.74

      Romaine Lettuce / Chicken / Bacon / Parmesan / Caesar Dressing / Garden Spinach Wrap

    • Butera’s Club Wrap

      $15.21

      Coleslaw / Ham / Turkey / Bacon / Pepperjack Cheese / Thousand Island Dressing / Sun-dried Tomato Wrap.

    • Chicken & Spinach Wrap

      $14.69

      Spinach / Chicken / Provolone Cheese / Mayo / Garden Spinach Wrap

    • Pesto Gouda Wrap

      $15.21

      Spring Mix / Chicken/Bacon / Smoked Gouda Cheese / Pesto Mayo / Garden Spinach Wrap

    • Veggie Wrap

      $13.64

      Spring Mix / Red Onion / Black Olives / Tomatoes / Sweet Peppers / Mushrooms / Garden Spinach Wrap

    • Pasta

      Served with Choice of a Cup of Soup or Salad/Garlic Toast. Substitute Gluten-Free Penne and Garlic Toast +$2.49 Upgrade to Bowl of Soup +$1.50

    • Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

      $18.89

      Fettuccine / Alfredo Sauce / Chicken / Parmesan

    • Chicken Parmesan

      $18.89

      Spaghetti / Grandma B’s Red Sauce / Hand-Breaded Chicken Fingers / Mozzarella Cheese

    • Chicken & Broccoli Penne

      $18.89

      Penne / Garlic Sauce / Broccoli / Chicken / Parmesan

    • Baked Ziti

      $18.36
      $2.61 - Add 2 Meatballs

      Penne / Grandma B’s Red Sauce / Seasoned Ricotta / Mozzarella Cheese / Parmesan

    • Spaghetti & Meatballs

      $17.84
      $+1.31 - Bake with Mozzarella

      Spaghetti / Grandma B’s Red Sauce / 2 Meatballs / Parmesan

    • Mac & Cheese

      $17.31
      $+2.61 - Add a Stuffed Pepper

      Elbows / Multi-Cheese Sauce / Topped with Panko

    • Sandwiches

      Served with house made tortilla chips. Substitute Side Options +2.99 regular potato wedges, sweet potato wedges, French fries, mac salad, coleslaw, or house salad. Substitute a Gluten Free roll for +$2.49.

    • Smoked BCBP Tenderloin Sandwich

      $19.94

      Smoked Tenderloin/Arugula/BBQ Sauce / Bleu Cheese Crumbles

    • B-52 Meatball Bomber

      $15.74

      Meatballs / Grandma B’s Red Sauce / Provolone Cheese / Hoagie Roll

    • Greek Chicken Pita

      $16.79

      Spring Mix / Red Onion / Black Olives / Tomatoes / Banana Peppers / Feta Cheese / Tzatziki / Pita

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich

      $14.69

      Grilled Chicken / Cajun Seasoning / Pepperjack Cheese / Coleslaw / Mayo / Roll

    • BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Meatloaf

      $18.36

      Meatloaf / Bacon / Pepperjack Cheese / Coleslaw / Cajun Remoulade/ Hoagie Roll

    • Beef On Weck

      $16.26

      Roast Beef / Kummelweck Roll / Served with Au Jus and Horseradish

    • Butera’s Stinger Sandwich

      $18.36

      Shaved Prime Rib / Chicken Finger (Choice of Sauce) / Lettuce / Tomato / Choice of Bleu Cheese or Mayo / Hoagie Roll

    • Burgers

      All Burgers are ½ lb. Hand-Pressed and Served on a House-Made Roll. Served with Tortilla Chips, Seasoned Wedges, or a Choice of a Cup of Soup. Substitute Side Options (+$2.99) Sweet Potato Wedges, French Fries, Mac Salad, Coleslaw, or House Salad. Substitute a Gluten Free roll for +$2.49

    • Peanut Butter Rocket Burger

      $18.89

      Arugula / Brick Oven Roasted Beer Onions / Roasted Garlic / Roasted Jalapenos / Bacon / Cheddar / Peanut Butter

    • Mozzarella Caprese Burger

      $17.84

      Roasted Tomatoes / Fresh Mozzarella / Pesto Mayo / Balsamic Glaze

    • Mushroom Chianti Burger

      $17.31

      Mushrooms Sauteed in a Chianti Reduction / Cheddar Cheese

    • French Onion Burger

      $17.31

      Brick Oven Roasted Beer Onions / Sauteed Banana Peppers / Provolone / Roasted Garlic Aioli

    • Stuffed Pepper Burger

      $19.41

      Stuffed Banana Pepper / Provolone / Marinara

    • Butera’s Original Burger

      $16.79

      Coleslaw/American Cheese/Thousand Island

    • Stuffed Mushroom Burger

      $18.36

      Spinach / Stuffed Mushroom / Smoked Gouda Cheese / Marinara / Roasted Garlic Aioli

    • BEC Burger

      $18.89

      Bacon / Fried Egg / Smoked Gouda Cheese / Pesto Mayo

    • Jalapeno Popper Burger

      $18.36

      Jalapenos / Cream Cheese

    • Surf & Turf Burger

      $21.51

      Arugula / Crab Cake / Cajun Remoulade

    • 1885 Burger

      $18.89

      Coffee & Brown Sugar Rub / Brick Oven Roasted Beer Onions / Fresh Mozzarella / Balsamic Glaze

    • Cheeseburger

      $16.26

      American Cheese

    • Turkey Burger

      $18.89

      House-Made Quinoa Turkey Burger / Spinach / Pickled Red Onion / Provolone / Roasted Garlic Aioli

    • Veggie Burger

      $18.89

      4 oz. “Beyond Meat”® Veggie Burger / Pickled Red Onion / Smoked Gouda Cheese

    • Hand Crafted Brick Oven Pizzas

      All pizzas made with our twist on my grandfather’s traditional Italian dough recipe. Turn any 8” Pizza into a Calzone +$2.00 | Gluten Free Pizza (12”) available +$4.00 to 14” Pizza Price

    • Available Pizza Toppings

      Meats: Sausage / Ham / Pepperoni / Chicken / Meat-balls / Bacon / Anchovies
      Vegetables: Jalapenos / Onions / Sweet Peppers / Roasted Red Peppers / Broccoli / Banana Peppers / Green Olives / Spinach / Black Olives / Mushrooms / Grape Tomatoes / Pineapple
      Garnishes: Balsamic Glaze / Basil
      8” - $1.50 14” - $2.25 each

      Extra Sauce: $.99
      *Additional $1 Charge: BBQ, Honey Mustard, Cajun, Honey Garlic, and Garlic Parmesan
      Specialty Sauces +$1.00: BBQ / Honey Mustard / Cajun (wet or dry) / Honey Garlic / Garlic Parm

    • Margherita

      $14.69 (8")
      $18.89 (14")

      Marinara / Fresh Mozzarella / Garlic Olive Oil / Fresh Basil

    • Chicken & Spinach

      $15.74 (8")
      $19.43 (14")

      Garlic Butter / Chicken / Spinach / Mozzarella / Cheddar

    • Steak

      $18.89 (8")
      $22.04 (14")

      Garlic Butter / Shave Prime Rib / Brick Oven Roasted Beer Onions / Roasted Red Peppers / Mozzarella / Cheddar / Pesto Mayo

    • Chicken Finger

      $16.79 (8")
      $20.99 (14")

      Bleu Cheese / Chicken Fingers (Choice of Sauce) / Mozzarella / Cheddar

    • Pesto Chicken

      $17.99 (8")
      $20.99 (14")

      Pesto Mayo / Chicken / Spinach / Roasted Red Peppers / Mozzarella / Balsamic Glaze

    • Ol’ Blue Eyes

      $18.89 (8")
      $22.04 (14")

      Seasoned Ricotta / Salami / Capicola / Prosciutto / Pepperoni / Meatballs / Mozzarella

    • White

      $13.64 (8")
      $17.84 (14")

      Garlic Olive Oil / Italian Seasoning / Grape Tomatoes / Onion / Mozzarella

    • Stuffed Banana Pepper

      $16.79 (8")
      $22.04 (14")

      Seasoned Ricotta / Marinara / Stuffed Banana Peppers / Mozzarella / Cheddar

    • Beef On Weck

      $15.99 (8")
      $19.99 (14")

      Creamy Horseradish Sauce / Roast Beef / Mozzarella / Cheddar / Au Jus / Kummelweck Crust

    • Stinger

      $17.99 (8")
      $20.99 (14")

      Bleu Cheese / Shaved Prime Rib / Chicken Fingers (Choice of Sauce) / Mozzarella / Cheddar

    • Sriracha Chicken Club

      $15.99 (8")
      $19.99 (14")

      Sriracha Ranch / Chicken / Bacon / Mozzarella / Pepperjack

    • Build Your Own

      $9.96 (8")
      $13.11 (14")

      Start with our cheese pizza and add toppings

    • Personal Calzone

      $14.69

      Seasoned Ricotta / Mozzarella / Your Choice of 2 Toppings / Served with Marinara

    • Dinners

    • Chicken & Waffle

      $17.31

      Belgian Waffles / Boneless Wings / Coleslaw / Chef Sauce

    • Prosciutto Salmon BLT

      $15.74

      Arugula / Tomato / Cold Smoked Salmon/Prosciutto / Bacon / Garlic Aioli / House-Made Bread / Served with Seasoned Potato Wedges

    • Fried Chicken

      $15.74

      4 Pieces of Breaded Fried Chicken / Coleslaw / Biscuit / Served with seasoned potato wedges

    • Fish Fry

      Fridays or when available! Substitute Side Options (+$2.99) Sweet Potato Wedges, French Fries, or House Salad

    • Beer Battered Fish Fry

      $16.79

      Fresh Beer Battered Haddock / Macaroni Salad / Coleslaw/Bread / Lemon / Seasoned Potato Wedges

    • Brick Oven Broiled Fish

      $17.84

      Fresh Haddock / Choice of Lemon Pepper or Cajun Seasoning / Macaroni Salad / Coleslaw / Bread / Lemon / Seasoned Potato Wedges

    • Beverages

    • Pepsi Products

      $2.61

      Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Orange Crush, Dr. Pepper, Sweet Tea, Unsweetened Tea, Lemonade, Ginger Ale

    • Other Beverages

      $2.61

      Apple Juice, Cranberry Juice, Orange Juice, Coffee (Regular or Decaf), Hot Chocolate, Hot Tea (Regular or Decaf)

    • Saranac Shirley Temple

      $3.14

    • VBH Root Beer

      $5.24